When to Hire Your First Marketer

Hi there! Welcome back to RoleCall; a newsletter for founders, early-stage operators, and tech leaders looking to hire the right people at the right time. Today we’re breaking down a critical startup role: the first marketer in a B2B SaaS company. We’ll look into why it matters, when to hire, what to look for, and how to get it right.

‍

🔍 Why This Role Matters (especially in B2B)

The first marketer is one of the most misunderstood early hires. It’s easy to over-index on logo recognition or deep industry expertise and miss the real need: someone who can build.

This role is especially important because early traction needs amplification in order to stoke real growth. A lot of people believe that effective marketing = leads. And that’s true. But your first marketer isn’t just generating top-of-funnel interest, they’re:

• Turning nuanced product value into crisp, clear messaging that resonates with your audience
• Enabling sales with the right materials, positioning, and insights
• Building early repeatable systems across content, campaigns, and channels
• Driving both inbound and outbound pipeline in partnership with GTM
• Synthesizing the voice and feeling tone of your company, both internally and externally

Your first marketer can ensure early momentum sticks and that sales and product are aligned.

‍

🕒 When to Hire

You’re ready for your first marketer when:

• You’ve closed early customers beyond your founder network and have achieved proof of early product-market fit
• Your sales team is cobbling together messaging, decks, events, or one-off campaigns
• You’re juggling multiple contractors without cohesive ownership
• You’re approaching Seed+ or Series A and need repeatable pipeline generation

If you’re pre-revenue or still pivoting, don’t hire yet. You need someone to embed deeply in customer discovery, not run automated campaigns that cloud your brand while you test what resonates. But once you have a clear signal, it’s time.

‍

🧠 What Great Looks Like

The ideal first marketer is a T-shaped generalist with sharp instincts and hands-on experience building. It’s great if they have Seed or Series A experience, but don’t ignore the bootstrapper, the former founder, or the person who’s helped launch a new offering from 0-1.

You want someone who:

• Has owned both pipeline and brand in a fast-moving, early-stage context
• Can write, execute, analyze, and iterate across content, events, email, and paid media
• Has worked cross-functionally with sales, product, and CS
• Has set up early systems or processes
• Brings a resourceful, curious, and self-directed mindset

As Alexandra Kane, VP of Revenue at Chalk, shared with us, the best early marketing hires are often "stretch directors"; low-ego, high-ownership marketers who are transparent about their strengths and weaknesses, and open to eventually being layered as the company grows. She emphasized hiring people who’ve built from Seed or Series A, not just those who scaled a behemoth like Datadog at $500M ARR.

Look for people who:

• Have managed contractors or vendors
• Know how to set interstitial milestones for experiments
• Are comfortable building before scaling
• Have had success (and some failure) at the early stage, and can tell you why

‍

🎯 What Kind of Marketer Do You Actually Need?

One of the most common founder questions:
“Should I hire someone focused on product marketing or demand generation?”

The truth? It depends on your stage, motion, customer type, and your biggest current bottleneck.

• If your product is complex and customers are asking “what exactly does this do?”, you likely need someone with a strong positioning and messaging muscle, someone who can translate your roadmap into customer-facing narratives and arm your sales team with content that actually moves deals forward. Think: product marketer with range.
• If you’ve nailed the story but no one’s hearing it, you might need someone with a demand generation mindset, someone who can set up early campaigns, test channels, track conversions, and fill the top of the funnel while keeping CAC in check.

The best early marketing hires don’t cling to job descriptions. They build what’s needed, learn fast, and grow with the company. Hire for depth, but bet on adaptability.

‍

⚠️ Common Pitfalls

Avoid these traps when hiring your first marketer:

• Hiring someone too junior and expecting strategic outcomes
• Hiring someone too senior who can’t, or won’t, get in the weeds
• Over-prioritizing industry experience instead of functional versatility
• Failing to give them clear goals or ownership
• Expecting them to succeed without context, collaboration, or founder involvement

Alexandra Kane also underscored the importance of CEO alignment on expectations and metrics. Even at the director level, your first marketer should have a seat at the table and a clear line of sight into how their work impacts overall company goals.

‍

❓ Interview Questions That Reveal the Real Thing

Here are a few to get past the fluff and vanity metrics:

1. “What did overall revenue growth look like during your time at your last company (or last two companies)?”
2. “How were you goaled in your last role? Did you hit those goals? Why or why not?”
3. “Tell me about a successful channel strategy you built from scratch and why it succeeded.”
4. “Tell me about a campaign that failed, why it failed, and what you did next.”
5. “If you had to build a martech stack from scratch, where would you start?”
6. “Describe a time you influenced company strategy.”
7. “Have you ever had to market to an audience you didn’t understand? How did you ramp up?”

You’re looking for signs of ownership, adaptability, structured thinking, quantifiability, and business acumen.

‍

📈 What About a VP of Marketing?

Your first marketing hire should likely not be a VP. Not yet.

You need a builder, someone who’s close to the work, hands-on with execution, and capable of learning and iterating quickly. A VP comes later, when:

• You have validated acquisition channels that need scaling
• You’re managing multiple robust functions (demand gen, product marketing, brand)
• You need someone to lead, hire, and allocate resources at the org level

If you're pre-Series B, start with someone who knows how to do the work before you hire someone to manage the people doing it.

‍

💼 Hiring Your First Marketer?

Let’s talk. We’ve helped companies B2B SaaS companies like Amplitude, 6Sense, and WalkMe hire high-performing, values-aligned leaders across GTM, G&A, and R&D. If you’re building and ready to find a storyteller who can also drive pipeline, we’d love to help.

‍

Thanks for reading. If you found this useful, feel free to share it with a founder, operator, or hiring manager in your orbit.

Until next time,

Alex Smith
Co-Founder, Full Umbrella Talent
LinkedIn | Website

‍